The Importance of Financial Analysis for Commercial Real Estate Investors

In the fast-paced world of commercial real estate investment, success often relies on the adept navigation of complex financial waters. Much like skilled sailors charting their course through turbulent seas, investors must navigate with precision, balancing the currents of risk and reward to maximize returns. With a strategic approach and deep understanding of market dynamics, investors can uncover lucrative opportunities amidst the waves, while steering clear of potential hazards. In this article, we'll embark on a journey through the depths of financial analysis, equipping you with the knowledge and strategies needed to sail confidently in the competitive waters of commercial real estate.

Topic 1: Decoding Cap Rates
To embark on our journey, let's start by demystifying the concept of cap rates. At its core, the cap rate serves as a vital metric for assessing the profitability of a commercial property investment. By comparing the property's net operating income (NOI) to its purchase price, investors can gauge with one simple number the annual return on their investment as a percentage. This metric can then be utilized to compare and contrast various investment opportunities. One drawback for investors that utilize leverage: cap rates do not take into account the power of leverage. It's essential to remember that cap rates are not static and can vary based on market conditions, property type, and risk factors. As such, investors must remain flexible and adapt their analysis to reflect changing dynamics in the market.

Topic 2: The Power of Market Analysis
No discussion of financial analysis would be complete without delving into the importance of market analysis. As the foundation of informed decision-making, market analysis provides invaluable insights into cap rate trends, rental rate trends, vacancy rates, demographic trends, and job creation/destruction. By conducting thorough research and benchmarking against comparable trade areas, investors can gain a competitive edge and make data-driven investment decisions.  

Topic 3: Unraveling Comparable Sales
One of the key tools in the investor's arsenal is the analysis of comparable sales, or "comps." By examining recent sales of similar properties in the market, investors can glean valuable insights into prevailing cap rates and market trends. However, deciphering comps requires a keen eye for detail and an understanding of the nuances that differentiate one property from another. Through careful analysis and due diligence, investors can leverage comps to refine their cap rate calculations and identify opportunities for value creation. In addition to cap rates investors should capture data on the price per unit or price per square foot of the comps. Comps should be compared with the replacement cost of like-kind properties. If a brand-new, state-of-the-art multifamily property in a Class A location can be built for $275,000 to $300,000 a unit, does it make sense to buy a 40+-year-old property with deferred maintenance in an inferior location for the same price per unit? 

Topic 4: Assessing Risk Factors
In the high-stakes game of commercial real estate investment, risk assessment is paramount. From tenant turnover to market volatility, numerous risk factors can impact the performance of your investment. By conducting a comprehensive risk assessment, investors can identify potential pitfalls and devise strategies to mitigate downside risk. Whether it's evaluating tenant quality, lease terms, escape clauses, or property conditions, a thorough understanding of risk factors is essential for making informed investment decisions. 

Topic 5: Setting Acceptable Target Returns
We live in a world of negative leverage. With negative leverage, the cost to borrow is higher than the cap rate. Stated another way, an investor who buys all cash without any leverage will receive the same return as their cap rate (e.g. $600,000 NOI on a $10 mm purchase is 6% return and 6% cap). Because of negative leverage, if you borrow $6 mm (at 6.5% on a 30-year amortization schedule and invest $4 mm in cash) the cash on cash return is only 3.62%. So why would anyone do this? Because the investor is comfortable with their basis and they know interest rates are cyclical, If the property can be refinanced at 3.5% on a 30-year amortization schedule the cash-on-cash return pops to 6.92%. During the Covid Pandemic Era of 2020 to 2022 we arranged multiple fixed-rate loans in the 2.65 to 3.5% range.

Topic 6: Crunching the Numbers: Calculating NOI
At the heart of cap rate analysis lies the calculation of net operating income (NOI). By subtracting operating expenses from gross rental income, investors can determine the true profitability of a property investment. However, accurately calculating NOI requires attention to detail and an understanding of the various expenses that impact property performance. From property taxes and insurance premiums to maintenance costs and management fees, every expense must be accounted for to arrive at an accurate NOI figure. If the Seller has owned a property for a long period, their assessment is likely to be very low. What are the norms of the municipality for re-assessment? Is this being factored into the numbers?

Topic 7: Fine-tuning Risk Tolerance
Whether you're aiming for stable cash flow or capital appreciation, setting clear investment objectives is essential for guiding your analysis. By aligning your target return with your investment goals and risk tolerance, you can identify properties that offer the best opportunity to achieve your desired outcomes. Are you more comfortable with a conservative approach focused on income stability or are you willing to take a more aggressive strategy aimed at maximizing growth and maximizing NOI expansion? If you want to sleep more soundly at night, a diverse rent roll with no correlation between tenants may be your best choice. This is the reason multifamily properties and self-storage facilities continue to thrive.  

Topic 8: Establishing a Purchase Price, Navigating Negotiations and Due Diligence
Armed with your target return and calculated NOI, it's time to apply the target cap rate to determine the estimated value of the property. By dividing the NOI by the target cap rate, investors can arrive at a valuation that aligns with their investment objectives. With a preliminary valuation in hand, it's time to put your analysis to the test during negotiations and due diligence. Whether you're negotiating with sellers or conducting inspections and audits, attention to detail is critical at every stage of the process. By leveraging your analysis to identify potential value-add opportunities and assess risk factors, you can negotiate from a position of strength and ensure that your investment meets your expectations.

Topic 9: Fine-Tuning Your Analysis for Market Conditions
As seasoned investors know, financial analysis is not a one-size-fits-all approach. Market conditions, interest rates, and economic indicators can all impact cap rates and property valuations. To stay ahead of the curve, investors must continually refine their analysis and adapt to changing dynamics in the market. Whether it's adjusting your target return or revising your risk assessment, flexibility is key to success in the ever-evolving landscape of commercial real estate investment.

Topic 10: Unlocking the Door to Profitable Investments
Get out and look at properties. Kick the bricks. Meet with industry-leading professionals. Become an expert in a niche within a niche within a niche so that when a property comes on the market, you know instinctively if it is a good deal or not. 

The importance of financial analysis cannot be overstated. It serves as the compass guiding investors through the complexities of market fluctuations and risk management. Now, armed with knowledge and strategies, it's time to take action. Whether you're a seasoned investor or just starting out, I urge you to apply these principles diligently in your investment endeavors. Dive into the market, conduct your analysis, and seize the opportunities that await. Remember, success in commercial real estate investment is within your reach. So, let's embark on this journey together and unlock the door to profitable investments. Happy hunting!

Author: David Repka

About the Author:
David Repka is the Co-Founder of Bison Financial Group in St. Petersburg, FL.
Bison arranges debt and equity financing for commercial real estate investors and developers.
Bison has relationships with investors across the risk spectrum funding acquisitions, renovations, and new construction.

Click to learn more about:
Bison Financial Group